THE NAZI-SOVIET PACT



At Munich in September 1938 the British and French prime ministers met Adolf Hitler and surrendered to his demands. Chamberlain and Daladier consented to the partition of Czechoslovakia and Hitler's annexation of the Sudetenland, and gave the Czechoslovaks nothing but a solemn guarantee of the integrity of the remnant. Prague felt obliged to acquiesce. The Czechs feared that accepting only Soviet aid would convert their country into another Spain. They dared not fight alone if the British and French washed their hands of them.

Chamberlain arrived home with the unfortunate phrase, "peace in our time," and the conviction that appeasement had succeeded. Whatever his conviction, it was deadly true that Britain and Prance were in no military position either to fight or to bargain effectively. Many in the West were ashamed of Munich. Many Czechoslovaks never forgot the experience of being sacrificed to their enemies by their friends. Hitler, who had received as a gift what he had been prepared to fight for, was jubilant.

The deception of Munich was soon exposed. In October and November the helpless Prague government had to cede Teschen as the result of a Polish ultimatum, yield a strip of territory holding a million people to Hungary, and grant full autonomy to Slovakia and Ruthenia, now renamed ''Carpatho-Ukraine.'' For a time Ruthenia was the scene of much real or alleged pan-Ukrainian agitation under Berlin sponsorship, which seemed to portend grave Nazi-Soviet tension.

Nevertheless, Stalin, in his report to the 18th Party Congress on March 10, 1939, brushed aside Western forecasts of trouble over the Ukraine as designed "to provoke a conflict with Germany without any visible grounds.'' Declaring that the "non-aggressive" states were ''unquestionably stronger than the Fascist states,'' he argued that their failure to resist Hitler was motivated not by weakness but by desire to embroil the Nazis with the Soviets. He warned against "war-mongers who are accustomed to have others pull the chestnuts out of the fire for them,'' and proclaimed the Soviet Union's intention to stay out of a "new imperialist war'' which was ''already in its second year." The Soviet "Political Dictionary" of 1940 described Stalin's report as raising "the question of the good neighborly relations between the Soviet Union and Germany. This declaration of Comrade Stalin," the article added, ''was properly understood in Germany."

It is now known not only that this assertion was true but also that Stalin's declaration fell on already receptive Nazi ears. Until the end of 1938 Hitler hoped for a compact with Poland at Soviet expense, in which he would receive Danzig and the Corridor in exchange for supporting Polish gains in the Ukraine. When Poland did not respond, he was turning to the idea of a partition of Poland in concert with the Soviet Union.

On March 15 Hitler sent German troops to occupy Bohemia and Moravia, set up Slovkia as an "independent'' state, but sacrificed his tiny Ukrainian ''Piedmont'' by giving it to Hungary. Thus he simultaneously made clear to the West that his ambitions exceeded the boundaries of German-speaking lands and to the Soviet Union that his much-bruited ''designs on the Ukraine" might at least temporarily be laid aside for purposes of diplomatic discussion.

Much British opinion was now clamoring for an end to ''appeasement'' as well as an approach to the Soviet Union. After the occupation of the core of Czechoslovakia, even Chamberlain lost his illusions about Hitler. He asked the Soviets what their attitude would be if Rumania were attacked and thus launched a series of Anglo-Soviet exchanges which continued into the summer. On March 31 he guaranteed Poland against attack and, after Mussolini seized Albania, on April 13 he guaranteed both Greece and Rumania. Meanwhile Hitler had extorted Memel from Lithuania by simple ultimatum, and he now began to demand Danzig and the Polish Corridor from Poland openly.

In September 1938 the Soviet Union had been isolated and ignored. Beginning in March 1939 she was ardently courted as a likely ally by both the Western powers and the Nazis. On May 3 Stalin replaced Litvinov with Molotov as foreign commissar. Thus departed the man publicly identified with the policy of ''collective security.''

Nevertheless, the British and French pushed on with negotiations for a pact to halt further Nazi aggression. In the meantime discussions about a Nazi-Soviet trade pact were proceeding. On June 15 the Soviet chargé d'affaires in Berlin passed on a message to the Nazis that the Soviet Union was trying to decide whether to conclude the pact with the British and French, drag out negotiations further, or undertake a rapprochement with Germany. He addied that ''this last possibility, with which ideological considerations would not have to become involved, was closest to Soviet desires."

Thenceforth the Soviet Union was negotiating secretly with the Nazis and openly with the British and French at the same time. If it had chosen to take it, the West had ample warning of what was in store. Molotov continually raised the Soviet price for a pact, but the plainest danger signal was an article by Zhdanov in Pravda on June 29, in which he said he could not agree with his friends who thought Britain and France were sincere in the negotiations which were taking place. The British and French did not exhibit any hastiness, at any rate. When they sent a military mission to Moscow in August, it went by leisurely boat.

However, Hitler was in a great hurry. An attack on Poland was scheduled for late August. By the end of July the Nazis realized that they must reach agreement with the Soviets very soon if these plans were to be safely implemented. It seems fairly clear that on the night of August 3 Hitler agreed to pay the Soviet price for a pact. Mussolini was left in the dark about his plans. The Italians learned only on August 11 that Hitler was bent on war, and the news threw them into a panic. On the night of August 19 the Nazi-Soviet trade treaty was signed. The next day Hitler telegraphed Stalin with a request that he see Ribbentrop on August 22 or 23. When he received Stalin's assent, Hitler pounded on the wall with his fists and shouted, "I have the world in my pocket!" On the night of August 23, 1939, the pact was concluded. It contained the provision which only totalitarians could insert, that it was to take effect as soon as it was signed.

The public text of the Nazi-Soviet Pact was simply an agreement of nonaggression and neutrality, referring as a precedent to the German-Soviet neutrality pact of 1926. The real agreement was in a secret protocol which in effect partitioned not only Poland (along the line of the Vistula) but much of Eastern Europe. To the Soviets were allotted Finland, Estonia, Latvia, and Bessarabia; to the Nazis, everything to the West of these regions, including Lithuania. Each of the two signatories was to ask the other no questions about the disposition of its own ''sphere of interest." This nonaggression pact, coupled with the trade treaty and arrangements for large-scale exchange of raw materials and armaments, amounted to an alliance.

When confronted with the public text of the pact, the Western emissaries could only creep home quietly. For the moment the Soviet obtained immunity from attack by Hitler, the opportunity for considerable expansion, and noninvolvement in the war which opened with Hitler's Blitzkrieg against Poland on September 1. Britain and France entered this war on September 3. On September 17 the Soviets announced they were entering eastern Poland. Actually the line of the secret protocol was now shifted by mutual consent. The Nazi-Soviet boundary in Poland became the Bug River instead of the Vistula River. In exchange the Soviets were allotted Lithuania. The Polish state disappeared. The Soviet Union handed Vilna to Lithuania and acquired an area whose western boundaries were roughly the same as the Russian frontier of 1795, plus eastern Galicia.

For the moment World War II had no front, except for what was derisively called the Sitzkrieg or ''phoney war'' in the West, where neither the French nor the Germans attempted any serious offensive. In September and October the Soviet Union forced the three Baltic states to sign mutual assistance pacts, but for the moment left them independent.

The foreign reaction to the Nazi-Soviet Pact and the annihilation of Poland was one of shock and rage. The Communist parties abroad, which had no official warning of the Soviet switch, reacted with confusion. On September 6 Thorez and other French Communists joined their regiments, calling for aid to Poland, only to desert at Moscow's behest a few days later. Harry Pollitt, the British Communist leader, wrote a pamphlet unfortunately titled "How to Win the War," and after two weeks both he and his pamphlet had to drop from public gaze. The German Communists in exile made strange noises suggesting that the Allies were worse than Hitler. The general line was that already stated by Stalin in March, that the war was an ''imperialist'' one for the redivision of the world. The Communists said much more about Allied than about Nazi ''culpability,'' and demanded ''peace.''

The Soviets brought pressure on Finland for a pact comparable to those signed by the Baltic states, but Finland refused and on November 29 was invaded by the Red Army. Otto Kuusinen, a Finnish Communist in Moscow's reserve for such emergencies, was brought out and made head of a puppet government which conceded all Soviet demands. The Soviets thereupon declared that they were not at war with Finland at all. Western sympathy for the Finns mounted as they successfully resisted the Reds.

In 1939 the Soviet Union was expelled from the League of Nations. Britain and France, observing the apparent weakness of the Red Army, debated sending troops to aid the Finns, and actually decided to do so a few days before a Soviet-Finnish peace was concluded in March 1940. The Nazis also took note of Soviet military weakness and filed it for future reference. The peace was an important factor in Daladier's replacement by Paul Reynaud as French premier, just in time to be faced with a new Nazi offensive in the West.

On April 9 Hitler occupied Denmark and invaded Norway, where British forces landed and tried to resist. When they had been defeated and withdrawn from southern Norway (although troops remained in Narvik a month longer) , public opinion forced Chamberlain from office and on May 10 Winston Churchill became British prime minister, heading a coalition government including Labor.

On the day that Winston Churchill became prime minister, Hitler attacked the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxemburg, and France. A break-through at Sedan was followed by a Nazi advance which reached the Channel on May 21, splitting Allied armies and compelling the British evacuation of Dunkirk. The Dutch had already been overrun, and the Belgian king surrendered on May 28. On June 10 Italy belatedly declared war on Britain and France. The French army was already shattered. On June 16 Reynaud yielded the premiership to Marshal Petain, who sued for peace at once. Churchill's Britain was left alone.

The Soviets reacted sharply to the fall of France even before the signing of an armistice. Stalin ordered military occupation of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, and all three were ''admitted'' into the Soviet Union as constituent republics in July. In late June the Soviets also annexed Bessarabia and northern Bukovina. The annexation of Bukovina went beyond the line of the secret protocol of the pact with Hitler, which was to create some problems latter. All this was done by way of an ultimatum to Rumania. The Russians then used most of the annexed territory to create a new Moldavian SSR.

The Nazis as well seemed to be closing up to their side of the protocol line. In August and September they began to occupy the rest of Rumania, partitioned its Transylvanian province and gave much of it to Hungary, and forced the Rumanians to cede the southern Dobrudja to Bulgaria.

In July 1940 Hitler had secretly decided to prepare to attack the Soviet Union. In September a German-Italian-Japanese Tripartite Pact was signed, and although it stipulated that it would not affect the relations of any of the three powers with the Soviets, a certain deterioration in Berlin-Moscow amity had become apparent. In November 1940 Molotov visited Berlin for further discussions of a vague and grandiose kind, but Hitler did not cancel his plans for attack. On December 18, 1940, he issued the directive for operation Barbarossa, the code name for the invasion of the Soviet Union, to be launched in the middle of May 1941.

Beginning in August the Nazis were launching large-scale air attacks on Britain. They were also consolidating their influence in the Balkans. The line of the secret protocol ended where Bessarabia touched the Black Sea, and south of that point neither Nazis nor Soviets could formally object to what their partners did. Hitler now extended the Tripartite Pact, often called the Rome-Berlin-Tokyo Axis, by obtaining the adhesion of Hungary, Rumania, and Slovakia in November. After some tension with Moscow over Bulgaria, the Bulgaria also signed the Axis pact. German troops went where the pact did.

In late March 1941 Yugoslavia added its signature to the Axis pact, but the government was promptly overthrown by a pro-Western coup. Immediately Hitler attacked and overran Yugoslavia and Greece as well. In doing so Hitler incidentally extricated Mussolini from a gravely embarrassing position. After his declaration of war in June Mussolini had attacked Greece from Albania, but had been forced to retreat under a successful Greek counterattack.

The brief Balkan campaign compelled Hitler to postpone "Operation Barbarossa" for a month, but its success left him in control of the whole continent up to the Soviet border, either directly or by way of his allies Mussolini and Franco, except for neutral Portugal, Sweden, and Switzerland. Even in Finland the government had accepted his aid in joint preparations for attacking the Soviet Union.

Western sources warned the Soviets that a Nazi attack was imminent. It is till uncertain whether Stalin and his colleagues expected the attack. Evidently the Soviets were still thinking in terms of better relations with the Nazis, deliveries to whom were maintained with scrupulous fidelity throughout the period of the pact, as well as with Hitler's Japanese allies. In the spring Foreign Minister Matsuoka came to Europe, and in April a Soviet-Japanese neutrality pact was signed, acclaimed by Izvestiia as an ''historic reversal in the relations between Russia and Japan.'' Stalin conducted a remarkable public demonstration of affection for all Germans and Japanese who were in sight as he was bidding farewell to Matsuoka at the railway station. At that moment the Nazi attack was two months away. The Soviets, of course, did not know that. For that matter, neither did the Japanese.

The night before the attack, Mototov summoned Count Schulenburg, Nazi ambassador in Moscow, told him that there were indications that the Germans were dissatisfied with the Soviets, and begged him to explain what had brought about the existing state of affairs. Schulenburg professed himself unable to say, and departed. A few hours later, however, he was back with all declaration of war on the Soviet Union. The Nazi invasion occurred, with Finnish, Rumanian, and other aid, all along the front from the Arctic Ocean to the Black Sea, on June 22, 1941.


Send comments and questions to Professor Gerhard Rempel, Western New England College.